15 Absorbing and Enthralling Supernatural Mysteries and Thrillers

Posted on June 29, 2019

by April S

Welcome to our appeal series where we’re highlighting a variety of books to help our readers find that next great read. In each post you’ll find books that share similar appeal or elements like genre, pacing, tone, storyline, writing style, characters, etc.

Haunting, creepy, suspenseful and surprising. The novels in this blog post are perfect for fans of gothic fiction, ghost stories, paranormal, horror, mysteries and thrillers.


Supernatural-Themed Reads

1. Ashley Bell by Dean Koontz

Appeal: Fast-Paced, Suspenseful, Intricately Plotted, Compelling and Creepy

Who is Ashley Bell? A must-read thriller from bestselling author Dean Koontz. Perfect for readers of dark psychological suspense and modern classics of mystery and adventure. Brilliantly paced, with an exhilarating heroine and a twisting, ingenious storyline.

2. Fellside by M.R. Carey

Appeal: Compelling, Creepy and Suspenseful

Confronting the possibility that she might be forced to spend the rest of her life in a maximum security prison on the edge of the Yorkshire Moors, Jess Moulson discovers that the prison is haunted by the ghost of a little boy who imparts a chilling message.

3. Grief Cottage by Gail Godwin

Appeal: Southern Gothic, Coming-of-Age Stories, Atmospheric and Character-Driven

Living with his reclusive aunt after his mother’s death, young Marcus befriends the ghost of a boy who was thought to have died with his parents during a hurricane fifty years earlier, but the boy seems to have a mysterious agenda.

4. Mind Game by Iris Johansen

Appeal: Fast-Paced, Intricately Plotted, Menacing and Suspenseful

Searching for a long-missing treasure in Scotland, Jane MacGuire experiences vivid dreams of a girl in danger at the same time she reconnects with a volatile ex and is confronted by stunning changes in the lives of those closest to her.

5. The 7 1/2 Deaths of Evelyn Hardcastle by Stuart Turton

Appeal: Action-Packed, Compelling, Creepy, Intricately Plotted and Stylistically Complex

Doomed to repeat the same day over and over, Aiden Bishop must solve the murder of Evelyn Hardcastle in order to escape the curse, in a world filled with enemies where nothing and no one are quite what they seem.

The Dead House by Billy O'Callaghan
The Grip Of It by Jac Jemc
Glass Town by Steven Savile

6. The Broken Girls by Simone St. James

Appeal: Ghost Stories, Compelling, Creepy, Intensifying, Intricately Plotted and Well-Crafted Dialogue

More than sixty years after one of four friends in a reputedly haunted boarding school goes missing, journalist Fiona Sheridan resolves to learn her sister’s fate before a harrowing discovery is made.

7. Providence by Caroline Kepnes

Appeal: Compelling, Creepy, Haunting, Intricately Plotted, Horror

A tale of two childhood best friends follows Jon, a boy with a strange power that can harm those he most loves, as he aims to protect his friend, Chloe, while he searches for answers.

8. The Dead House by Billy O’Callaghan

Appeal: Ghost Stories, Compelling, Haunting and Menacing

Escaping to the rugged west coast of Ireland where she restores an old cottage, Maggie, a successful young artist recovering from an abusive relationship, invites her friends up for a weekend during which an old Ouija board summons something sinister that becomes a force of inescapable horror.

9. The Grip Of It by Jac Jemc

Appeal: Horror, Compelling, Creepy and Intricately Plotted

After a young couple moves into a house, they are taunted by strange changes that keep occurring in the house and, in their search for answers, find disturbing facts about their neighbors and the couple who lived in the house before.

10. Glass Town by Steven Savile

Appeal: Fast-Paced, Plot-Driven and Suspenseful

Series: Joshua Raines novels, book 1

Seventy years after a rising London actress disappeared with one of two rival brothers, a descendant investigating the mystery explores a magical cityscape to understand the factors that destroyed his grandfather’s life.

The Woman in the Woods by John Connolly
The Secret Life of Souls by Jack Ketchum and Lucky McKee

11. The Grownup by Gillian Flynn

Appeal: Ghost Stories, Gothic Fiction, Creepy and Compelling

The Edgar Award-winning, creepy short story about a soft-core sex worker-turned-grifting psychic is now published for the first time as a standalone book.

12. The Hush by John Hart

Appeal: Gothic Fiction, Atmospheric, Compelling and Menacing

Ten years after the disappearance of his twin sister, an event that transformed his life and hometown, Johnny Merrimon struggles to avoid notoriety by moving into the wilderness, a decision that his longtime friend, Jack, fears is subjecting Johnny to malevolent forces.

13. The Woman in the Woods by John Connolly

Appeal: Haunting, Disturbing, Moody, Intricately Plotted and Richly Detailed

When the body of a woman who apparently died in childbirth is discovered in the Maine woods, private investigator Charlie Parker shadows the police investigation in order to discover the woman’s identity and the fate of her baby.

14. Watch Me Disappear by Janelle Brown

Appeal: Compelling, Moody and Intricately Plotted

When a woman goes missing during a hike in California’s Desolation Wilderness, her devastated family is forced to come to terms with her secretive nature.

15. The Secret Life of Souls by Jack Ketchum and Lucky McKee

Appeal: Psychological Fiction, Fast-Paced and Complex Characters

A gripping family drama that brilliantly explores the relationship between a young girl and her dog—and the mysteries that lie within.

Photo of girl browsing books in a library. Image by klimkin from Pixabay.
Looking for More Recommendations?
New Catalog Features

Did you know about our new enhanced catalog features?

Let’s say you really enjoyed this book:

Scroll down in the record to find:

Read-alikes (similar titles and authors)

Simply select a title or author you like under “read-alikes” and you’ll be presented with a brief explanation of why you might like the book and/or author recommendation.

Story elements like appeal, character and genre

Let’s say you really enjoy creepy novels.

It’s now easier than ever before to find more great “creepy” reads using the Library catalog.

Simply select the desired story element (i.e., creepy) and additional reading recommendations pop up on your screen.

It’s that easy!

And in some cases … book lists

Here you’ll find great book lists powered by Novelist.

We hope you find these catalog enhancements helpful.

Happy reading!

Did you like this blog post? Keep up to date with all of our posts by subscribing to the Library’s newsletters!

Keep your reading list updated with our book lists. Our staff love to read and they’ll give you the scoop on new tv-series inspired titles, hobbies, educational resources, pop culture, current events, and more!

Looking for more great titles? Get personalized recommendations from our librarians with this simple form.